Misinformation in Mass Media
Oct. 20th, 2008 01:17 am![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png)
Hey VPers!
I'm watching "Sex... with Mom and Dad" with Dr. Drew on MTV, and I noticed some misinformation in an "exercise" about Truth v. Myth in relation to sexual health. (For those who don't know, the whole premise of the show is to get kids and parents to open up about sex in an effort to foster better sexual information and such)
The two things in particular that bothered me were:
Truth: "Anal sex can get you pregnant." The card they got said that there can EASILY be drippage down to the vagina that can result in pregnancy.
Myth: "Pulling out is effective 30% of the time" They didn't detail the card for this one, but it was presented as a "pulling out is never effective" type thing.
My issues:
We get questions regarding both of these things all the time here on VP - as far as the anal sex issue is concerned, as far as *I* am aware, it is not an easy or common thing for there to be drippage that would seep to the vagina. I understand the ulterior motive - to get kids to use condoms for any sexual activity, but does the end justify the misinformation?
For pulling out - we talk about that a LOT here at VP, and it is most certainly more than 30% effective when used properly! In fact, Planned Parenthood cites a 73% success rate for typical use. For this topic specifically, is it more important for kids to be pushed to wear condoms and think that withdrawal is not effective at all, or is it more important for them to have all the correct information? I understand that thinking "Oh, it works 73% of the time" could lead to kids forgoing condoms and such, but with comprehensive education (which seems to be the goal of this show) is the lying really necessary?
Thoughts? Comments?
EDIT: And Dr. Drew just told a 19 year old with 20-25 partners that she "undoubtedly" had genital warts/HPV, and asked her if she had seen any warts. I think there is a big difference between telling someone about their risk levels and saying "Oh I'm sure you have XYZ"
I'm watching "Sex... with Mom and Dad" with Dr. Drew on MTV, and I noticed some misinformation in an "exercise" about Truth v. Myth in relation to sexual health. (For those who don't know, the whole premise of the show is to get kids and parents to open up about sex in an effort to foster better sexual information and such)
The two things in particular that bothered me were:
Truth: "Anal sex can get you pregnant." The card they got said that there can EASILY be drippage down to the vagina that can result in pregnancy.
Myth: "Pulling out is effective 30% of the time" They didn't detail the card for this one, but it was presented as a "pulling out is never effective" type thing.
My issues:
We get questions regarding both of these things all the time here on VP - as far as the anal sex issue is concerned, as far as *I* am aware, it is not an easy or common thing for there to be drippage that would seep to the vagina. I understand the ulterior motive - to get kids to use condoms for any sexual activity, but does the end justify the misinformation?
For pulling out - we talk about that a LOT here at VP, and it is most certainly more than 30% effective when used properly! In fact, Planned Parenthood cites a 73% success rate for typical use. For this topic specifically, is it more important for kids to be pushed to wear condoms and think that withdrawal is not effective at all, or is it more important for them to have all the correct information? I understand that thinking "Oh, it works 73% of the time" could lead to kids forgoing condoms and such, but with comprehensive education (which seems to be the goal of this show) is the lying really necessary?
Thoughts? Comments?
EDIT: And Dr. Drew just told a 19 year old with 20-25 partners that she "undoubtedly" had genital warts/HPV, and asked her if she had seen any warts. I think there is a big difference between telling someone about their risk levels and saying "Oh I'm sure you have XYZ"