Depending how large he is, he may have torn you a little bit (hence the residual bleeding).
He also may not have broken your hymen all the way. Mine got broken the first time when a guy was fingering me (HORRIBLY PAINFUL WAY TO LOSE IT by the way), and I spotted for a few days. But when I had sex with him for the first time, I still bled a bit. It may be that your hymen wasn't torn all the way the first time.
Cramping is normal too, you're using muscles in a way you've never used them before.
A lot of girls don't bleed because we live in a world of bicycles, gymnastics, horseback riding, wrestling, and fingering, all which can cause the hymen to break pre-sex.
hymen help
He also may not have broken your hymen all the way. Mine got broken the first time when a guy was fingering me (HORRIBLY PAINFUL WAY TO LOSE IT by the way), and I spotted for a few days. But when I had sex with him for the first time, I still bled a bit. It may be that your hymen wasn't torn all the way the first time.
Cramping is normal too, you're using muscles in a way you've never used them before.
A lot of girls don't bleed because we live in a world of bicycles, gymnastics, horseback riding, wrestling, and fingering, all which can cause the hymen to break pre-sex.