personally i wouldnt waste the money on either of them. its best just to clean with water. your vagina is a self cleaning oven and doesnt need these extra chemicals/cleansers to make it *fresh*. most likely these products wil just cause more irritation and or infections. if you was your *bits* everyday in the shower you shouldnt smell super strongly. your scent can also be related to what you eat, if you are eating things that have a strong scent your vag will smell stronger as well. i had a link to a list of foods that make your scent stronger but i cant locate it now....